You have the VA. Why a $0-premium Advantage plan is worth a look
September 10, 2026
Listen Now
Subscribe
Ready to talk with an advisor?
The advisors at American Retirement Advisors have been having these conversations for over 25 years. A no-cost discovery session is the fastest way to find out where you actually stand.
Schedule a Discovery Session
Show Notes
Eddie and Betty's Conversation
Welcome back to The American Retirement Advisor. I'm here with Eddie, as always, and today we are diving into something that comes up constantly with our veteran listeners. If you or someone you love has VA health care, and you've been wondering whether Medicare Advantage even makes sense on top of it, this episode is for you. We're working through Ian Schaeffer's latest piece, part three of his Healthcare in Retirement series, and I have to say, this one surprised me in a few places.
That landed on me too, and I read a lot of this stuff. The piece opens with a line I keep thinking about. Ian says this is the topic where the kindest advice tends to be the wrongest. And that's not a small thing to say. He's talking about veterans specifically, people who have earned their care, and the well-meaning but genuinely harmful guidance that gets passed around.
So paint me the picture of who this veteran is. Who is Ian writing for?
Someone who served, who has VA health care, whose doctor is at the VA, whose prescriptions come through VA mail order. And at some point, a friend or a coworker, or someone at a desk who really should have known better, told them they didn't need Medicare Part B. Because hey, the VA covers you. Why pay for something you don't need?
And that advice sounds so reasonable on the surface.
It does. But Ian already addressed why it's wrong in an earlier part of the series. The short version is that VA coverage is not the same as coverage from a current employer, which matters enormously for Medicare's rules around late enrollment. If you skip Part B at 65 thinking the VA has you covered, there's no special window to fix it later. You just get the penalty. That's it.
So today's piece assumes you did the right thing. You kept Part A, you kept Part B. Now the question is, why would you even look at a Medicare Advantage plan on top of your VA coverage? Especially those zero-dollar premium plans you see advertised everywhere.
Right. And to answer that, you have to understand the foundational rule that makes this whole conversation necessary. The VA and Medicare do not work together. They don't coordinate. Ian actually quotes Medicare's own language on this, and it's worth sitting with. Every time you get health care, you have to choose which benefit to use. They don't split the bill. They don't fill each other's gaps automatically.
So it's not like having two insurance cards where one picks up what the other leaves behind.
Not at all. The VA pays for care at VA facilities, or care it has pre-authorized somewhere else. Everything outside of that, an emergency room two states away, a specialist with a shorter wait, the hospital in the town where your grandkids live, that's Medicare's job. The VA doesn't reach that far.
I think a lot of people assume there's some kind of handshake between the two systems. Like of course the federal government coordinates its own programs.
You'd think. But no. And this is actually why the VA itself, on its own website, answers the question of whether you should sign up for Medicare at 65 with a simple yes. Their reasoning is straightforward: having Medicare means you're covered if you need to go to a non-VA hospital or doctor. The VA is telling its own patients, get Medicare too.
So now you're in that non-VA world. What does it actually look like? What are you working with?
This is where Ian lays out the first big reason a veteran might want to look at Medicare Advantage. Original Medicare pays 80 percent of the approved amount for most outpatient care after you've met the deductible. You cover the other 20 percent. And the sentence Ian says to read twice is this: there is no yearly limit on what you pay out of pocket under Original Medicare, unless you have some kind of supplemental coverage.
No ceiling. At all.
So if you have a genuinely bad year medically, 20 percent of that, with nothing stopping it, can get very large very fast. And a veteran who gets most of their care through the VA might think, well, I'm barely using Medicare anyway, so the risk is low. But that's exactly the wrong way to think about insurance. The cap matters most in the year you didn't see coming.
And Medicare Advantage plans are required to have that ceiling.
By law, every one of them has to have a yearly out-of-pocket maximum. Once you hit it, you pay nothing more for covered Part A and Part B services that year. For 2026, CMS sets the highest that in-network limit can be at ninety-two hundred and fifty dollars, and many set theirs lower than that. So for a veteran who is mostly using the VA and just wants a backstop for everything else, a option that adds that ceiling for a zero-dollar monthly premium is, as Ian puts it, exactly what it sounds like. A cap on the worst year, for the cost of the Part B premium you were already paying.
It's the same amount you'd pay anyway, just for Part B on its own.
Exactly. The plan itself doesn't add to that monthly cost if it's a zero-premium plan. You do pay copays when you actually use it, and we'll come back to the honest catches in a minute. But the base cost isn't new money out of your pocket.
Ian's second reason caught my attention because it came from a real caller, not a hypothetical.
It's a great moment in the piece. He said he wanted to keep Medicare because, and I'm paraphrasing here, if I'm somewhere and I can't use VA, I want that coverage there. That's it. That's the whole reason. And it's so practical. Winters somewhere warm. Grandkids in another city. A wait at the VA that you'd rather not sit through when a local specialist could see you next week.
That wait piece is real. People don't always talk about it directly, but it's real.
It is. And the Advantage plan gives that non-VA care a structure. A network. A defined set of copays instead of an open-ended 20 percent. You know what you're stepping into before you step into it.
There's a third reason Ian mentions, and it's a little different from the first two. This one is about things neither the VA nor Medicare traditionally covers.
Vision, hearing, dental. Ian notes that most Advantage plans offer extras that Original Medicare doesn't cover, and that these vary plan to plan. He's careful about it, though. He says those extras are not why you choose a plan. They're a reason to look. There's a distinction there that matters. Don't pick a plan because of the free gym membership or the dental benefit. Pick a plan because the structure and the network and the cap make sense for your life. The extras might be a bonus.
He actually mentions a caller who had military coverage and the one gap was the eye doctor. Like that was the thing that fell through.
Right, and a plan with a vision benefit might close that gap. But again, it's a reason to look, not a reason to decide. The decision has to be built on the bigger picture.
Okay, so let's get into the honest catches, because Ian doesn't gloss over them. Zero-dollar premium is not zero cost.
Ian's really direct about this. You must keep Part A and Part B, and you must keep paying that Part B cost, which in 2026 is two hundred two dollars and ninety cents a month, to be in any Advantage plan at all. That's not optional. That cost doesn't go away. The plan's own monthly charge might be zero, but that Part B bill is still there.
And you have copays when you actually use the plan.
You do. And the plan has a network, which means the doctors and hospitals you'd realistically use outside the VA need to actually be in that network. Otherwise the plan isn't doing what you need it to do. Ian also raises the fair criticism that if you never use the plan, it might feel like money out the door. And he addresses that directly. His answer is that never use is a guess about the future. The cap is not a guess. The cap is real and it's there on the day you need it.
That's a really useful way to frame it. You're not paying for what you expect to use. You're paying for protection against what you didn't expect.
Which is what insurance is. At its core, that's the whole job.
What about availability? Is this even an option everywhere?
Ian gives some numbers here that I found interesting. In Arizona this year, 100 percent of people with Medicare have access to a zero-premium Advantage plan. In Nevada it's 97 percent. So in those states the access is essentially universal. But he's also clear that availability varies, and that which plan makes sense for you is completely dependent on your ZIP code, your doctors, and your travel patterns. There's no one-size headline.
What about prescriptions? Because a lot of veterans are getting their medications through VA mail order, and I imagine that changes the math.
Good news on this one. Ian says VA drug coverage counts as creditable coverage, which means the Part D late enrollment penalty doesn't apply to you as long as you keep your VA coverage. So you're protected there. Now, if the Advantage plan you join happens to include drug coverage, you gain the option of filling something at a local pharmacy instead of waiting on VA mail order. But the rule is you can't use both for the same prescription at the same time.
So it's not double-dipping, it's just flexibility.
And that option matters more than people might expect. For someone who's traveling or who needs something quickly, having the option to fill locally rather than waiting for mail order could genuinely matter.
Ian wraps up by talking about what a Certified Medicare Planner actually does differently in this situation. And I want to make sure we give that section its due because I think people underestimate how much detail goes into this.
It's a lot of ground to cover correctly. Ian lays it out pretty specifically. They start with where you actually get care and where you actually travel, then check whether the non-VA providers you'd realistically turn to are inside the plan's network -- the same real-world care picture we talked about earlier. Then they compare the plan's cap and copays against what a Medicare Supplement would cost, because for some veterans a supplement is actually the better backstop, and for others it's money that's genuinely wasted. That comparison matters and it's not obvious from the outside.
And there's the piece about making sure your VA creditable-coverage letter is on file.
Yes, and this is one where I'd really encourage anyone listening to bring this to one of our advisors directly, because the exact mechanics of how that documentation flows and what needs to be where and when, that's the kind of detail where you want someone who does this every day, not a general explanation from a podcast. The stakes of getting it wrong are real. A miscalculated penalty isn't fixed easily.
And Ian's last note on the planner piece is very much in the spirit of everything else in the article. They never let the zero-dollar premium be the reason for anything.
Which tells you a lot about the mindset you want in a planner. It's a feature. It is not a strategy. The strategy is built on your life, your care, your geography, your risk. The price tag is just one data point.
I want to go back to something for a second, because I think there's an emotional layer to this conversation that we haven't said out loud yet. These are veterans. People who served. And the kindest advice, as Ian puts it, has often been the wrongest. Someone told them not to worry about Medicare because the VA had them. And that advice came from a place of care.
And it cost some of them real money. The penalty for skipping Part B isn't a slap on the wrist. And once you've missed the window, it follows you. That's a hard thing to sit with, especially if the advice came from someone you trusted.
Which is why this kind of careful, here's-exactly-what-the-VA-says, here's-exactly-what-Medicare-says reporting matters. Ian checked every rule against the VA's own pages and Medicare's own pages. He's not editorializing.
And the conclusion he lands on is pretty clear. The VA itself says get Medicare. Medicare Advantage, for veterans in the right situation, adds a ceiling, adds flexibility, and adds structure for the care that happens outside the VA world. It's not for everyone, but it deserves a real look rather than a dismissal.
Let me ask you something a listener might be wondering. Is there any scenario where a veteran with VA coverage should just stick with Original Medicare and skip the Advantage plan entirely?
Yeah, there is, and Ian actually addresses it. For some veterans, a supplement might be a better backstop than an Advantage plan. The supplement works differently, it fills in Original Medicare's gaps including that 20 percent, and it typically has a broader network. Whether that's better than an Advantage plan depends on the individual's situation, the costs involved, how often they'd be using non-VA care. That comparison is genuinely what a Certified Medicare Planner walks you through. I wouldn't try to work that out on your own based on a podcast or an article, because the numbers are specific to your ZIP code and your circumstances.
And this is why Ian ends with a phone number. If you served and nobody has ever walked you through this properly, the number is 602-281-3898. That's the kind of conversation our advisors are, in Ian's words, proudest of.
And there are also in-person workshops coming up, which I think are genuinely valuable because you can ask questions in the room. Friday, October 2nd, two locations. Foothills Library in Glendale at 10:30 in the morning, and Mustang Library in Scottsdale at 2:30 in the afternoon. No cost to attend. You can register at 123easymedicare.com/medicare-workshop, or call 877-220-1089.
Worth saying, they're presented by a brand of American Retirement Advisors. Not affiliated with Medicare, CMS, Social Security, or any government agency. Independent, educational, no sales pressure.
The libraries are just hosting the space, by the way. They're not affiliated with the event either. Just good neighbors, frankly.
I also want to flag that Ian says the next piece in this series is going to tackle the Part D question. You take no medications, so why would you pay for a drug plan? And the answer, as a preview, is that the penalty for skipping it is permanent, and the window to fix it only opens once a year. He says he'll do the arithmetic with real numbers. That one's worth watching for.
The permanent penalty piece is something people genuinely don't realize until it's too late. So yes, that next article is going to be important.
So if I'm summing up today's conversation for our veteran listeners, here's what we covered. The VA and Medicare don't coordinate. The VA itself says yes, get Medicare. Original Medicare has no out-of-pocket ceiling. Medicare Advantage, though, we talked about how that ceiling is built right into it, that protection we mentioned earlier. And that zero-dollar premium point we made earlier still sticks with me, because your monthly budget doesn't take a new hit just for having the coverage, even though Part B is still running in the background. Your VA drug coverage is creditable, so your Part D standing is protected as long as you keep it. And the right plan, whether Advantage or something else, depends on your life, not a headline.
And the thing I keep coming back to from Ian's piece is that sentence about the kindest advice being the wrongest. Good intentions don't protect you from bad information. Getting this right matters, and getting it wrong has real financial consequences that follow you for years.
If you're a veteran, or if you love one, and this conversation opened up questions you didn't have answers to before, please don't sit on it. Call 602-281-3898, come to one of the workshops, or visit 123easymedicare.com. You served. You deserve to have someone sit down with you, look at your actual situation, and make sure the coverage you've earned is actually working for you. Thank you so much for spending this time with us today.