What we learned when the 2027 Medicare plans came out | The American Retirement Advisor PodcastSkip to main content
HomePodcastEpisode 224

What we learned when the 2027 Medicare plans came out

October 4, 2026

Show Notes

Eddie and Betty's Conversation

Betty

Welcome to The American Retirement Advisor. I'm Betty, and Eddie's here with me in the studio today, and we are diving into something that affects millions of people right now, this week, because Medicare's Annual Enrollment Period is coming up fast. The 2027 plans just went live on Medicare.gov, and our COO Ian Schaeffer has been in the weeds pulling every single plan and writing about what the data actually says. Eddie, you read this piece this morning.

Eddie

I did, and I'll say, Ian opens by calling himself an engineer who loves this part of the year because the data finally exists. Which is the most Ian sentence ever written.

Betty

Ha, okay, fair. But here's why I wanted to spend a whole episode on this. Most people hear Annual Enrollment and think, I'll just keep what I have. And what Ian is showing is that keeping what you have might mean something very different in 2027 than it did in 2026.

Eddie

That is the whole point of the article, and it's a good one. The plan looks the same from the outside. Same name, maybe the same premium. And then you open it up and the numbers inside have shifted.

Betty

So walk me through what they found when they pulled the plans on October 1.

Eddie

For Scottsdale, ZIP code 85255, Medicare.gov listed 101 options from 18 companies. That's up from 17 companies and 88 Advantage options for 2026. So more choice, which is good, but also more to sort through.

Betty

101 plans.

Eddie

101. And Las Vegas had 81 from 11 companies. So if you're planning to just browse Medicare.gov on your own, that's a lot of browsing.

Betty

That's like walking into a grocery store where every aisle has been rearranged and some of the products changed their labels.

Eddie

And some of the prices are in the fine print, which, yes, is what we're about to talk about.

Betty

Okay, so the deductible thing. Because Ian flagged this at a public workshop, and apparently the one-line warning was just, there are more of them this year. More deductibles. What does that mean in actual numbers?

Eddie

So in Maricopa County they looked at the 52 standard Advantage plans, meaning not the special needs plans, just the regular ones. In 2026, 11 of those 52 had a medical deductible. In 2027, 16 of them do. And one more hadn't even posted its number yet when they checked.

Betty

So you could have a plan where there was nothing last year and now there is one.

Eddie

Correct. And that deductible is not showing up in the headline premium. You're not going to see it in the ad.

Betty

Which is kind of wild when you think about it. Because if your plan added one, how would you even know unless you went looking?

Eddie

You wouldn't. That's why Ian is saying open your Annual Notice of Change, which your plan sends you, and find three specific numbers for 2027.

Betty

What are they?

Eddie

Medical deductible, drug deductible, and out-of-pocket maximum. Compare each one to the 2026 number. If any of them went up, that's the conversation you need to have before October 15.

Betty

That's when Annual Enrollment opens, and you have until December 7 to make a change, and that change starts January 1.

Eddie

You got it.

Betty

Now what about the drug deductible side? Because I feel like people think of that separately.

Eddie

And it is separate from the medical side. So the most any plan can charge on the drug side went from $615 in 2026 to $700 in 2027. And of the 9 stand-alone drug plans in Maricopa, 6 of them set theirs at the full $700.

Betty

Six out of nine went straight to the max.

Eddie

Right to the ceiling.

Betty

That tells you something.

Eddie

And if your drug plan was at the old maximum, the new maximum is $85 higher. Your plan letter will tell you exactly where yours landed.

Betty

Okay, and then there's the out-of-pocket maximum, which I think is the number people understand the least. Can you explain what that is?

Eddie

So the out-of-pocket maximum is the ceiling. It's the most an Advantage plan can make you pay in a year for covered medical care in its network. Once you hit it, the plan pays for your covered care in its network for the rest of the year. Doesn't include prescriptions, that's a separate cap. But for medical care, that's your worst-case number for the year.

Betty

And it changed significantly.

Eddie

The median across those 52 standard plans went from $4,425 in 2026 to $4,825 in 2027. And the highest among the 52 went from $7,900 to $8,900.

Betty

Wait, $8,900? In one year? For one person?

Eddie

That's the maximum a plan can ask you to pay before it takes over completely. And if you have a surgery, a hospital stay, anything significant, that number matters a lot.

Betty

And the plan might look identical on paper. Same name, same premium, different ceiling.

Eddie

Ian wrote that. He said a plan can look the same on the cover and still ask you to carry more of the risk. Which is why their advisors read that line first.

Betty

I like that framing a lot. It looks the same on the outside but a few chapters are different.

Eddie

And you find out when you need the chapter.

Betty

Right, which is the worst time to find out. So let's talk about what Medicare.gov can't even tell you yet, because this surprised me when I read it.

Eddie

So as of October 1, three things were missing. No doctor information loaded for 2027, so the site cannot tell you if your doctor takes the plan. Star ratings say coming soon on every 2027 plan. And the dental flag reads not specified for every plan in both ZIP codes.

Betty

That's the thing though, even if the plan's own detail page lists cleanings and crowns.

Eddie

Yep. The data field says not specified. So if you're trying to use Medicare.gov to compare dental benefits right now, you're not getting an accurate picture from that field alone.

Betty

And the doctor thing, that's the one that would send me into a panic. My doctor doesn't take this plan?

Eddie

And that's exactly why Ian's team went straight to the insurance companies' own Summary of Benefits documents, with their provider directories next, rather than waiting for Medicare.gov to catch up.

Betty

So the government website is, at this moment, a starting point but not the whole story.

Eddie

That's the honest summary. It's normal for early October, Ian says that. But it means there's real legwork behind getting an accurate answer.

Betty

If someone's sitting at home right now wanting to check on their own doctors, what does Ian say to do?

Eddie

Go to the plan's own directory, not Medicare.gov. And then call the doctor's office directly to confirm they'll be in network in 2027. Because a directory can lag too.

Betty

Old fashioned, but it works.

Eddie

Every time.

Betty

Okay, so I want to talk about what Ian describes at the end of the piece, because he writes about what a Certified Medicare Planner does differently, and honestly it reads like a behind-the-scenes look at what happened in their office this week.

Eddie

He was at his desk watching it. He's not an advisor, he's their COO, their engineer, and he's describing what he saw. Every plan in the county pulled on the first morning. Numbers compared year over year. Summary of Benefits documents gathered before a single client meeting.

Betty

So when someone sits down with one of their advisors next week, the advisor already knows which plans added a deductible.

Eddie

Which ones raised their limits. Which ones Medicare.gov can't fully describe yet. The homework was done before the client walked in.

Betty

That's the part that most people don't see. They see the meeting. They don't see all the work that led up to it.

Eddie

And Ian's point is that the recommendation is only as good as that work. If you're just reading the headlines, you're missing the numbers that change what a plan costs you.

Betty

So for someone who wants to just do a quick gut check themselves before they call anyone, what's the practical first move?

Eddie

Pull out your Annual Notice of Change. Your plan sends it to you every fall. Find the medical deductible for 2027, the drug deductible for 2027, and the out-of-pocket maximum for 2027. Write those three numbers down. Compare them to last year. If any of them went up, you have a question worth asking.

Betty

You can do that in five minutes.

Eddie

That's all it takes, and then you go into any conversation with an advisor knowing what changed on your plan specifically.

Betty

And if you don't have that notice yet, or you can't find it, what then? I mean, is there a way to get that information?

Eddie

You can call your plan directly and ask for those three numbers for 2027. They can tell you. And if you want someone to help you read them, that's a question for one of the advisors. The specific rules around what counts toward different deductibles, what's in network versus out, those details are worth getting right from someone who's read the documents.

Betty

Because as Ian's piece shows, even Medicare.gov isn't giving you the complete picture right now.

Eddie

And it's early October. Things update. But enrollment opens October 15. So the window between now and when you need to decide is not that wide.

Betty

It runs from the 15th to December 7. Changes start January 1. That's the span.

Eddie

Don't wait until the last day.

Betty

Ha, spoken from experience of people who wait right to December 6th.

Eddie

Every year without fail.

Betty

Okay, let me ask you one more thing, because I know some people listening are thinking, my premium didn't go up, so I'm probably fine. What would you say to that person?

Eddie

That one number is just the start. Ian's whole piece is about the numbers that aren't the monthly payment. A deductible that appeared where there wasn't one before. An out-of-pocket ceiling that went up. A drug deductible at the legal maximum. None of those show up in what you pay each month.

Betty

So the premium is the sticker price and the other three numbers are what you might pay.

Eddie

That's a cleaner way to say it than most plan brochures manage.

Betty

I have my moments.

Eddie

You do.

Betty

Alright. If you want to read Ian Schaeffer's full piece, it's worth your time, especially if you're in Maricopa County or the Las Vegas area, because he's looking at those specific markets. And if you want to sit down with someone who has already pulled every plan and read the documents behind them, you can reach the advisors at American Retirement Advisors at 602-281-3898. That conversation costs you nothing, and right now, in the first two weeks of October, with enrollment opening on the 15th, it is the right moment to have it. Don't just roll over your plan. Find out what it's actually going to cost you in 2027.

Go Deeper

Read next on our site:

You Finished the Series

Up next: Take-Home Notes →
Browse the whole library
Back to all episodes

Ready to talk with an advisor?

The advisors at American Retirement Advisors have been having these conversations for over 25 years. A no-cost discovery session is the fastest way to find out where you actually stand.

Schedule a Discovery Session