Still the right drug plan? What the Letter Leaves Out, part three | The American Retirement Advisor PodcastSkip to main content
HomePodcastEpisode 227

Still the right drug plan? What the Letter Leaves Out, part three

October 7, 2026

Show Notes

Eddie and Betty's Conversation

Betty

Welcome to The American Retirement Advisor. I'm Betty, Eddie's here with me in the studio today, and we are talking about something that lands in a lot of mailboxes this time of year: that letter from your Medicare drug plan. The one that tells you what's changing. And the thing is, the letter sounds complete. It really does. But Ian Schaeffer wrote a piece about what that letter is actually leaving out, and Eddie, when I read it, I had a 'wait, really?' moment.

Eddie

Yeah, I had the same reaction. And I'm the numbers guy, so I figured I'd already know most of it. I did not.

Betty

So let's start with the most basic thing. You get the letter. It says your drug plan is changing. What is it NOT telling you?

Eddie

It's not giving you your total. Your personal, actual, what-are-you-going-to-spend-next-year number. The letter describes the plan. It does not know your list.

Betty

Your list meaning your prescriptions.

Eddie

Exactly. Your specific drugs, your specific doses, the specific pharmacy you walk into. The letter can tell you a drug moved to a different tier or now needs prior approval. It cannot add all of that up for you.

Betty

And that number, your total, where does it live?

Eddie

Medicare.gov. And Ian Schaeffer's piece makes the point that finding it takes about ten minutes. Which honestly surprised me, because people treat it like some big scary project.

Betty

Ten minutes. That's less time than I spend deciding what to have for lunch.

Eddie

To be fair, that decision is harder.

Betty

It really is. Okay, so what are the big changes for drug plans in 2027? Because the article lays a few out and some of them made me stop.

Eddie

There are three worth knowing. The one that surprised me most to see as a concrete number: the drug deductible cap went up. Used to be $615, now it's capped at $700 for 2027.

Betty

And plans actually charge that full $700?

Eddie

In Maricopa, six of the nine stand-alone options set theirs at the full $700. So not every one, but most of them.

Betty

Six out of nine. That's not a small number.

Eddie

And the second change is the out-of-pocket cap, which is the one people should really pay attention to. Last year the ceiling on what you'd pay for drugs in a year was $2,100. In 2027 it goes to $2,400.

Betty

So that went up by $300.

Eddie

Right. But once you hit it, the handbook language is pretty clear: you pay zero for your covered Part D drugs for the rest of the year.

Betty

I mean, that part is good. Once you're over that line, you're done paying.

Eddie

That part is genuinely good news, yes.

Betty

What's the third change?

Eddie

Fewer plans available. In Maricopa County specifically, they pulled the Medicare.gov data and found 9 stand-alone drug plans for 2027, down from 10 in 2026.

Betty

And if your plan is one of the ones that didn't come back?

Eddie

You should have gotten a different letter, not the standard annual notice. The article points people to their piece on what Ian Schaeffer calls the two letters, which covers your rights in that situation.

Betty

Okay, so back to this idea that the same plan can be the cheapest option for one person and one of the most expensive for their neighbor. That stopped me completely when I read that. How is that possible?

Eddie

Because the cost depends on which drugs you take, which tier each one lands on, and where you fill them. All three of those are personal. None of them are in the letter.

Betty

The pharmacy one really got me. You're saying the same pill, same plan, can cost different amounts depending on which pharmacy counter you walk up to?

Eddie

That's what the article says, and it's one of those things where when you see it you think, of course, but I never knew to look for it.

Betty

So how do you run your own check? Walk me through it without it sounding like a tech tutorial.

Eddie

Think of it like making a grocery list before you go to the store. You don't show up and try to remember everything. You gather your bottles first, or get a printout from your pharmacy, with the exact drug names and doses.

Betty

That's the list.

Eddie

That's your list. Then you go to Medicare.gov, enter your ZIP code, choose drug plans, and enter each prescription with its dose and how often you take it. And you pick your pharmacy.

Betty

And then what comes back?

Eddie

Every plan available to you, sorted by lowest yearly cost. Drugs plus premium, combined. Your current plan is in that list somewhere. And if it's not near the top, the article says that's worth a closer look before October 15.

Betty

That's when the Annual Enrollment Period opens.

Eddie

That's the start line. So running the check now, or soon, gives you time to act on day one.

Betty

Okay, but here's where I want to push a little. Let's say someone runs the search, finds the cheapest plan, and switches. Are they done?

Eddie

Not quite. And this is where the article gets into something most people skip. You have to look at the flags on each drug in the plan details, not just the total cost.

Betty

Meaning what, exactly?

Eddie

Three things. What tier is the drug on. Does it need prior approval, where your doctor has to submit paperwork before the plan will cover it. And is there a quantity limit.

Betty

Prior approval every few months sounds exhausting.

Eddie

On a drug you cannot do without, it's a real burden. The article puts it plainly: a plan can win on price and still ask your doctor for that paperwork on the one medication that matters most to you.

Betty

So you could switch to save money and then spend the year fighting with your insurance company over your prescription.

Eddie

That's the scenario. And it doesn't show up in the headline number. That's why you have to look at the details for each drug, not just the plan total.

Betty

I feel like that is the part of this conversation that is going to stick with people. It looks great, the plan wins on price, and then there's a catch buried in the fine print.

Eddie

And most people don't know to look for it until it's already January and they're mid-prescription.

Betty

Can those catches change mid-year? Like, can a plan change its drug list after you've enrolled?

Eddie

The article confirms it can happen mid-year, with notice. So the plan that fits in January is the one to recheck the following fall.

Betty

Which means this is not a one-and-done thing. You do this every year.

Eddie

That's the rhythm of it. Your drugs might be the same but the plan around them can shift.

Betty

Okay, I want to ask about something the article raises at the end, which is what happens when a person doesn't want to do all of this themselves. Or shouldn't have to.

Eddie

Right, and it describes what a Certified Medicare Planner does differently. It's not just running the search. It's running your full list, at your pharmacy, across every plan in your county, and then checking the flags on every drug, not just the total.

Betty

So they're doing all of that, but for each plan, for each drug, with someone who knows what they're looking at.

Eddie

And when the cheapest plan has a catch on one of your prescriptions, they find it before you do. That's the specific language in the article and it's a pretty good description of the value.

Betty

Because if you miss that catch yourself, you find out about it in March when you're trying to fill a prescription.

Eddie

And by then the fall window has closed.

Betty

Right. Not great timing.

Eddie

Understatement of the year.

Betty

Let me ask you something practical. If someone is sitting there right now thinking, I got my letter, I kind of skimmed it, I don't know if my plan is still the best one for me, what's step one?

Eddie

Get your prescription bottles out, or call your pharmacy and ask for a printout of everything you take with the doses. That is the only prep you need before you go to Medicare.gov.

Betty

And if the search itself feels like too much?

Eddie

The advisors at American Retirement Advisors can run it. Their number is 602-281-3898. I'd write that down. The specific details of how a planner walks through all of it, what they check, in what order, that's a conversation worth having with someone on their team.

Betty

Because there are details in each person's situation that the article can frame but can't answer for you specifically.

Eddie

That's why the personal conversation matters. It gives you the map. The planner knows your road.

Betty

I like that. Okay, let me just make sure we hit the things people need to remember from today, in plain language.

Eddie

That letter describes changes. It does not calculate your cost. Those are two very different points.

Betty

The deductible cap is now $700, and most stand-alone drug plans in Maricopa are charging the full amount.

Eddie

The out-of-pocket ceiling is $2,400. Once you hit it, you pay nothing, and that's really the point we were making before: zero cost on covered drugs from that moment straight through to December 31st.

Betty

And the total cost is not the whole story. You have to look at the tier, the prior approval requirement, and the quantity limit for each drug.

Eddie

Because a plan can look great on price and still make your life very difficult on a medication you depend on.

Betty

Ten minutes on Medicare.gov can tell you things your letter never will.

Eddie

Fewer than most people's lunch decisions take.

Betty

He brings everything back to that.

Eddie

It's a consistent theme in my life, yes.

Betty

Alright. Thank you for being here with us today. If you want to talk through your own situation with someone who knows Medicare drug plans inside and out, reach out to American Retirement Advisors at 602-281-3898. You can sit down with a Certified Medicare Planner, they will run your specific list, at your pharmacy, and tell you what your year looks like before you're locked in. That conversation costs you nothing. Ian Schaeffer's piece is worth reading too, it's clear and it walks you through each step of the search. Take care of yourselves, and go find your prescription bottles.

Go Deeper

Read next on our site:

Continue the Series

Next episode: Is your doctor still in network? What the Letter Leaves Out, part four →
All 5 episodes in What the Letter Leaves Out
Back to all episodes

Ready to talk with an advisor?

The advisors at American Retirement Advisors have been having these conversations for over 25 years. A no-cost discovery session is the fastest way to find out where you actually stand.

Schedule a Discovery Session