Is your doctor still in network? What the Letter Leaves Out, part four | The American Retirement Advisor PodcastSkip to main content
HomePodcastEpisode 228

Is your doctor still in network? What the Letter Leaves Out, part four

October 8, 2026

Show Notes

Eddie and Betty's Conversation

Betty

Welcome to The American Retirement Advisor. I'm Betty, and Eddie's here with me in the studio today, and we are back in the middle of our series on what your plan's Annual Notice of Change tells you versus what it leaves out. And today's installment is the one I think is going to surprise people, because it surprised me.

Eddie

Yeah, I appreciated the warning before we started recording, because I needed a minute with this one too.

Betty

So let's set the stage. You're on a Medicare Advantage plan. You get your letter. It has a section about network changes. What does that section actually say?

Eddie

Usually a sentence. Maybe two. Something like: it shifts from year to year, check next year's directory. And then it moves on.

Betty

That's it?

Eddie

That's it. Ian Schaeffer describes it really well in this piece. The letter is honest. It just hands the question back to you.

Betty

It doesn't say, here are your doctors, here's whether they're staying.

Eddie

No. It points you to a separate document, the provider directory. The directory is not in the letter. The letter just tells you it exists.

Betty

So the natural next move for most people is going to be: let me just pop over to Medicare.gov and check my doctors in the plan search tool.

Eddie

Right. And here is where this gets interesting.

Betty

Uh oh.

Eddie

Medicare.gov does have a step in the plan search where you can add your doctors. The plan results then show you a little check or an X for each doctor. That feature exists. It works. For 2026, it worked for 49 out of 52 standard Advantage plans in Maricopa County.

Betty

Okay, that sounds pretty good.

Eddie

For 2026. For 2027, when Ian Schaeffer's team pulled the data on October 1st, none of the 52 plans had the doctor information loaded. Zero out of 52.

Betty

Wait, really? The tool is just empty?

Eddie

They checked again on the evening of October 4th. Still none. The data simply is not there yet.

Betty

So this is happening right now, a week before the Annual Enrollment Period opens, when people are starting to make this decision.

Eddie

The piece says the data may still show up later this fall. But the message is clear: do not wait on it.

Betty

And even once it does show up, there's another catch buried in the article that I want to make sure people hear.

Eddie

The search looks up individual doctors, not hospitals. So even when the doctor data comes in, if your hospital is the thing that matters most to you, the tool won't help you there.

Betty

That's a meaningful gap. A lot of people, especially if they've got something ongoing, that relationship is the thing they absolutely cannot lose.

Eddie

Exactly. And Medicare.gov won't tell you either way.

Betty

So what do you actually do? Because I don't want people to just walk away feeling stuck.

Eddie

Two steps, and the article is really clear about this. Step one: go to each plan's own website, find the 2027 provider directory, and look up every single doctor you see. Primary care, each specialist, the hospital you'd want.

Betty

And they're emphatic about one thing there, right? Which directory you're looking at?

Eddie

Yes, and this tripped me up reading it the first time. One insurance company can run several different networks. So you cannot just go to the company's general website and search. You have to find the 2027 directory for the specific plan.

Betty

That feels like the kind of thing that would totally trip a person up. You think you checked, but you were looking at the wrong network the whole time.

Eddie

And then you enroll, and three weeks into January you find out your cardiologist is not in it.

Betty

Not a fun way to find that out.

Eddie

No. So that's step one. Step two is the one the article says people skip.

Betty

Which is?

Eddie

Call the doctor's office. And the piece gives you the exact question to ask: will you be in the network for this plan, by name, in 2027?

Betty

Not just in general. Specifically that plan, by name, for 2027.

Eddie

Because directories can lag behind real contracts. The article puts it well: the person at the front desk often knows before the website does.

Betty

I love that detail, because it's so counterintuitive. You would assume the official document is more current than whoever answers the phone at the office.

Eddie

But that front desk person is fielding these questions constantly. They know.

Betty

So you call, you ask the exact question, and then what does the article say to do with that information?

Eddie

Write down the date you called and who you spoke with. Because it also flags something a little sobering: plan materials typically include a line that says the provider network can change at any time during the year.

Betty

Wait, mid-year?

Eddie

Yep. The language Ian Schaeffer quotes says the network may change at any time and you'll receive notice when necessary. So even if your doctor is in network on January 1st, that's not a permanent guarantee for the whole year.

Betty

That is the part of this piece that got me. You do all this work, you confirm everything, and it can still shift underneath you.

Eddie

Which is exactly why the article says check every fall. Last year's answer doesn't automatically hold.

Betty

It's almost like you signed up for a gym, confirmed your favorite instructor teaches there, and then the gym hired them away mid-year.

Eddie

And mailed you a very brief notice about it.

Betty

Ha. Okay, so let me ask you something about the order of operations here. Because the article makes a specific point about what comes first when you're comparing plans.

Eddie

Doctors. That's the phrase from the piece. A Certified Medicare Planner does not start with premiums or drug costs or the extras. They check your doctors and your hospital against the 2027 directories, confirm the ones that matter most by calling the offices, and then, only then, compare the rest.

Betty

Because what's the point of finding a great premium on a plan where your oncologist isn't covered?

Eddie

None. You'd be saving forty dollars a month and paying out of pocket to see the person who matters most to you.

Betty

It's like buying a car because you love the color and then finding out it doesn't fit in your garage.

Eddie

I was going to say something less vivid, but yes. That.

Betty

I know you were. Okay, what does this look like in practice though? Because I think some people are picturing calling one office and being done. But how many doctors are we talking about?

Eddie

And that list we walked through a minute ago, your whole roster of providers, that's not a small thing to verify. If you've got a primary care doc, a cardiologist, and an endocrinologist, that's three calls minimum before you've even thought about the hospital.

Betty

And you're potentially doing that across more than one plan you're considering.

Eddie

Right. It's not impossible, but it's real work. And this year, because the Medicare.gov shortcut isn't there, it's not optional work.

Betty

Can I ask you something about the Maricopa County numbers? Because I want to make sure I'm understanding what they represent.

Eddie

Sure.

Betty

The 52 plans, that's specific to one county. Is this a nationwide issue or is it just that market?

Eddie

Maricopa is just what they checked. But the 2027 doctor data not being loaded into Medicare.gov, that's about the site itself. So I'd assume it affects far more than one area, but I wouldn't want to state a scope the article doesn't claim. And honestly, this is a great question to bring directly to an advisor who's checking this in real time.

Betty

Speaking of which, the article does mention what a Certified Medicare Planner does differently here. And it's basically everything we've been describing, but they're doing it for you.

Eddie

And they're not waiting for the website to catch up. The piece says they check your doctors and hospital against each plan's own 2027 directory, confirm with the offices, and then compare premiums and drug costs and extras. That's the sequence.

Betty

So if you're sitting here thinking, I'm not sure I have time to call three or four places across two or three plans, that's the kind of thing to hand off.

Eddie

The number in the article is 602-281-3898. That's the direct line to the advisors at American Retirement Advisors.

Betty

And I'd also say, if you're not sure whether the Medicare.gov data has come in yet by the time you're listening to this, that's another thing to just ask them. Because they keep checking it as the season goes, not relying on a snapshot from early October.

Eddie

The data may have arrived. Or it may still be blank. Either way, the two-step process, directory plus phone call, is still the more reliable approach.

Betty

Can we go back for a second to something that keeps bugging me? The letter itself. Because the article says the letter is honest.

Eddie

It is. It tells you the network changes, it tells you to check the directory. It doesn't lie.

Betty

But it also doesn't say: by the way, your usual backup tool for doing that might not have the data yet this year.

Eddie

No. It cannot say that. The letter is built from a government template, written before anyone knew what this year's website would show.

Betty

So it's honest in the way that a map is honest. It shows you the roads, but it doesn't tell you one of them is under construction right now.

Eddie

That's a good way to put it. The map is accurate. The conditions on the ground require a separate check.

Betty

And this year, what's happening is that one of the most commonly used tools for that review is not ready.

Eddie

Not as of early October. And the enrollment period doesn't wait.

Betty

Right, and let's get that timeline crystal clear for everyone listening. What's the window again?

Eddie

The Annual Enrollment Period runs October 15th through December 7th. The article doesn't give a specific date for when the Medicare.gov data might arrive, just that it may come during that window.

Betty

Which means if you wait to see if it shows up, you're burning through part of your enrollment period doing nothing.

Eddie

And if it never loads, you've lost time you needed.

Betty

Okay, let me ask you to do a quick summary pass, and I'll put it the same way I did with those Maricopa numbers: I don't want anybody leaving this episode without the three things they need to act on.

Eddie

Step one: don't wait for Medicare.gov's doctor search to populate. Go directly to each plan's own website and find the 2027 provider directory for the specific plan, not the company's general directory.

Betty

And look up everyone: primary care, specialists, hospital.

Eddie

Step two: call each office and ask that exact question Betty just mentioned, the one about whether they'll be in your specific plan's network come 2027. Write down who you talked to and the date.

Betty

Because the front desk person often knows before the website catches up.

Eddie

Step three: only after doctors are confirmed, then compare premiums, drug costs, and the extras.

Betty

That's the priority, every time.

Eddie

This year especially.

Betty

I want to flag one more thing from Ian Schaeffer's piece that I think is easy to miss in the middle of all this. The bit about mid-year changes.

Eddie

The network can change during the year.

Betty

Right. So even if you do everything perfectly, confirm every doctor, the plan materials reserve the right to change the network after you've enrolled.

Eddie

They'll notify you. But it can happen.

Betty

Which means this whole process isn't a one-time thing you do in November and file away forever. It's something you revisit every fall.

Eddie

That's the takeaway. Last year's answer is not automatically this year's answer.

Betty

I want to say something to the listener who might be feeling a little overwhelmed right now, because I could see how this episode could leave you feeling like there's a lot of moving parts and the tools you thought you had aren't working the way you expected.

Eddie

It's a fair feeling. This year does have an extra wrinkle.

Betty

But the thing is, the steps themselves are not complicated. They're just more manual than usual this year. Directory, phone call, confirm, then compare.

Eddie

And if you'd rather have someone who does this every day handle it, that's what the team at American Retirement Advisors is there for.

Betty

And you can read Ian Schaeffer's full piece, which is part four of this series, because there's more detail in there than we were able to get to today, including how this fits with the other things the letter leaves out.

Eddie

Tomorrow's piece is about the extras. Dental, vision, hearing. And apparently there's something about a little tooth icon on Medicare.gov that does not mean what you think it means.

Betty

Filing that away.

Eddie

You cannot make this stuff up.

Betty

If you're getting ready for the Annual Enrollment Period and you want someone to sit down with you and go through this the right way, doctors first, the number is 602-281-3898. That's the team at American Retirement Advisors. They check these directories, they make the calls, and they know what questions to ask. You don't have to figure this out alone. Thanks for listening.

Go Deeper

Read next on our site:

Continue the Series

Next episode: What do the extras really cover? What the Letter Leaves Out, part five →
All 5 episodes in What the Letter Leaves Out
Back to all episodes

Ready to talk with an advisor?

The advisors at American Retirement Advisors have been having these conversations for over 25 years. A no-cost discovery session is the fastest way to find out where you actually stand.

Schedule a Discovery Session