Why do they make you take the money out?
November 2, 2026
Listen Now
Subscribe
Ready to talk with an advisor?
The advisors at American Retirement Advisors have been having these conversations for over 25 years. A no-cost discovery session is the fastest way to find out where you actually stand.
Schedule a Discovery Session
Show Notes
Eddie and Betty's Conversation
Welcome to The American Retirement Advisor. I'm Betty, Eddie's here with me in the studio today, and we are diving into something that genuinely surprised a lot of people when it hit their mailbox. Required minimum distributions. RMDs. And Eddie, I want to start with the reaction people had to this, because Ian Schaeffer wrote about how many people downloaded his dad David's guide after the newsletter went out, and that tells you something.
It points to what's real: people have been ignoring this until they can't anymore, and then suddenly it's very interesting.
Which is the most human thing in the world. So let's back up for someone who has never heard the term. What is an RMD?
So at a certain age, the government says you have to start pulling money out of your Traditional IRA, your 401k, most workplace plans, every single year. Whether you need the money or not. And whatever comes out, you pay income tax on it.
That part always gets me. Like, I've been so disciplined, I don't need to touch this, and the government just says nope, take it anyway.
And pay us our cut. That's the part that lands for most people.
So where does this even come from? Who decided this was a good idea?
Well, the Individual Retirement Account was created back in 1974, through something called ERISA. And from the very beginning, the tax break came with a future obligation. The idea was always that you'd have to start pulling the money out at age 70 and a half.
Wait, 70 and a half? That's a very specific number.
It is. And that age has moved since then, which is actually one of the things they cover later in the series. Your birth year determines what your starting age is now. But the original deal was 70 and a half.
And then what happened in 1986?
The Tax Reform Act of 1986 took those rules and applied them across the board to workplace plans, 401ks, 403bs. So it wasn't just IRAs anymore. The uniform minimum distribution rules covered all of it.
So this has been baked in for fifty years and people are still surprised by it.
The idea hasn't changed once.
Okay so here's what I want to understand, because Ian Schaeffer's piece quotes David on this and I thought it was such a good way to put it. It's not a penalty. It's the back half of a deal.
Right, and that framing changes everything. Think about it this way. Every dollar you put into a Traditional IRA or a 401k went in before taxes. You got a deduction. The money grew for decades. And at no point did you pay tax on any of it.
So it's basically been sitting there untouched by the IRS the whole time.
The government was patient. But they weren't forgiving the debt. They were deferring it. And the RMD is where they come to collect.
That's the distinction I love, because I think a lot of people hear "tax deferred" and somewhere in their brain they translate that as "tax free.
That is the most expensive misreading in retirement planning.
Ha. Yeah. Okay so walk me through what actually happens in terms of notification, because Ian says most people meet their RMD in the mail.
By January 31st, your IRA custodian is required to notify you that an RMD is due for the year, and usually how much. So you get a letter.
And for someone who has spent decades not touching that account, getting that must be a shock.
The article specifically says that. For people who've been saving and never touching the account, that notice can be a surprise. Which is a very polite way of saying some people are completely blindsided.
January is already a rough month.
And now you've got a tax bill to go with it.
So let's talk about why this matters beyond just the withdrawal itself, because Ian's piece makes the point that RMDs don't just affect your account balance. They move other numbers.
This is the part that people genuinely do not see coming. The money you pull out is taxed as ordinary income. Same rates as a paycheck. And that income can bump your tax bracket, affect your Medicare premiums, change how much of your Social Security gets taxed.
Wait, that can make more of it taxable?
It can. Because it's income. And when your income crosses certain thresholds, more of your Social Security benefit becomes subject to tax.
That is a domino effect I do not think most people picture when they're 40 and putting money into their 401k.
Nobody's thinking about Medicare premiums at 40. They're thinking about growing the account.
And then what about the kids? Because Ian mentions that this even affects what children owe when they inherit it.
Right, and that's a whole layer that people don't think about. The tax obligation doesn't just disappear when you pass. Depending on how the account is handled, the people who inherit it may be dealing with their own distribution requirements and their own tax bills.
So you save your whole life to leave something to your kids, and if you haven't planned around this, you might be handing them a tax problem along with the money.
That is not the gift most people are picturing.
No it is not. And look, I think the specific rules on inherited accounts get complicated fast. The exact mechanics there are something I'd write down and bring to one of our advisors at American Retirement Advisors, because the details really do matter.
They've also changed in recent years, so getting current guidance on that one specifically is worth doing.
Okay I want to come back to the emotional piece here for a second. Because I think there's something in the way Ian frames this that's actually kind of generous toward people who didn't plan for it.
How do you mean?
He's not wagging a finger. The whole framing is, look, you made a deal a long time ago and you may have forgotten about it. Not that you were dumb or careless. Just that this was the second half of an agreement that felt very abstract when you made it.
And when you're 35 and getting a tax deduction, the idea that you'll owe on the back end feels so far away it barely registers.
It's like signing a lease and not reading the move-out clause. You'll get there eventually.
And then suddenly it's move-out day.
Exactly. So let's talk about what the series actually covers this week, because this week's series walks through David's guide in seven parts and I think the lineup is worth knowing.
There are a few that really stand out to me. The one about what happens if you miss an RMD, because the penalty has changed and can actually be waived under certain circumstances. And the one about Medicare premiums, because that connection is not obvious.
Wait, the penalty can be waived? I did not know that.
That's Thursday's installment. It's smaller than it used to be and there are situations where it can be set aside entirely. I don't want to get ahead of the specifics because the exact rules there are genuinely something to run by an advisor, but the key point is it's not always as catastrophic as people fear.
That's reassuring, actually. Because I think hearing the word 'penalty' makes everyone assume the worst.
And then they don't ask questions they should be asking.
What about the math piece? Wednesday is about how the calculation works.
So the article teases it as one division. One number divided by another. And I think that's a good way to describe it because people assume it's this complicated formula and it really isn't.
We'll get into the actual calculation when we cover Wednesday's piece. But I like that framing, one division. It demystifies it.
The thing that makes it complicated isn't the math itself. It's all the factors that feed into it. Account balance, age, whether you have a spouse who is significantly younger. Those details change the output.
And then Saturday is about charitable giving, which I want to spend real time on when we get there because that one surprised me.
Same. There's a smarter way to give to charity that connects directly to RMDs and it's not something most people are aware of.
Good surprises are the best kind. Okay so zooming back out to where we are today, which is part one, the foundation. If someone is listening to this and they're maybe in their 50s, pre-retirement, what's the most important thing to take away from just this piece?
That the time to think about this is not when the letter arrives in January. Knowing how RMDs work is what lets you plan around it instead of just reacting to it. That line is straight out of the article and it's the whole point.
And that it's even called a hidden history, that's not an accident. These rules have been around for fifty years and still manage to blindside people.
Which says something about how little retirement tax education most of us get along the way.
Your employer is not sitting you down at 35 to explain what will happen to your 401k at 73.
They're mostly just hoping you enroll in the plan.
Ha. Fair point. So if someone wants to go deeper right now, David's guide is available and Ian says it takes about ten minutes to read. At no cost to you.
That's a good return on a short read. Something that could affect decades of retirement income, and it costs you nothing but a little time.
And I think the bigger thing I keep coming back to is that this is educational, right? The guide, what we're doing here. But at a certain point you need someone looking at your specific numbers.
Because the general rules are one thing. What an RMD does to your particular tax situation, your Medicare, your Social Security, the account you're planning to leave your kids, those answers are individual.
Right. The domino effect we talked about lands differently for every person.
Significantly so.
So if any of this is sounding like something you need to look at more closely, the thing to do is sit down with an advisor who can look at your whole picture alongside your tax professional, not just one piece of it.
And the earlier you do that, the more options you have. That's just true with all of this.
That's just always true with all of it.
Waiting until the letter arrives limits the menu considerably.
Okay so we are going to be walking through each piece of this series this week, and today was the foundation: what an RMD is, where it came from, and why it touches so many other parts of your financial life. If you want David's guide right now, you can get it through the link in Ian Schaeffer's article. If you want to start a conversation about how this fits into your own plan, our team at American Retirement Advisors is the place to do that. Eddie, anything before we close?
Just that this is one of those topics where the more you understand it, the less scary it gets. It's not a trap. It's a deal. And deals can be planned around.
It's a deal. And you've got time to be smart about it. Thank you so much for spending time with us today. We'll see you in the next one.