Which Medicare situation is yours? All eighteen, sorted
September 27, 2026
Listen Now
Subscribe
Ready to talk with an advisor?
The advisors at American Retirement Advisors have been having these conversations for over 25 years. A no-cost discovery session is the fastest way to find out where you actually stand.
Schedule a Discovery Session
Show Notes
Eddie and Betty's Conversation
Welcome to the American Retirement Advisor podcast. I'm here with Eddie, as always, and today we are diving into something that I think is one of the most confusing corners of retirement planning, which is Medicare. Not in a dry, here-are-the-rules way, but in a here-is-what-actually-trips-people-up way. Eddie, I want to start with why Ian Schaeffer even wrote this piece, because I think that context matters.
Good to be here. So it came together as a kind of master index, eighteen parts of a healthcare-in-retirement series he's been building out, and the whole premise is that Medicare isn't one decision. It's closer to a hundred small ones, and the costly ones are hiding inside completely ordinary moments.
What does he mean by that?
He names three specifically: your last day at work, a letter in the mailbox, and a winter somewhere warm. Which sounds almost poetic, but each one of those can trigger a Medicare deadline or a penalty if you don't know what you're looking at.
And Open Enrollment is happening right now, so the timing of this piece is pretty deliberate.
October 15 through December 7. So yes, this is not an abstract conversation. People who need to make changes have a window open right now.
Okay, so Ian organized the whole series around life situations rather than just Medicare parts and rules. Which I love, because nobody wakes up thinking about Part B. They wake up thinking, I just left my job, now what?
Right, and that first situation is one where a lot of people get burned. If you leave a job and go onto COBRA, most people assume the COBRA coverage buys them time on Medicare enrollment. It does not.
Wait, really? It doesn't count?
Medicare does not treat COBRA as job coverage. So that eight-month window to sign up for Part B starts the month after your job ends, not when COBRA runs out. If you wait for COBRA to expire, you could be enrolling late.
And late enrollment means a penalty.
A permanent one. That's not a typo. It doesn't go away after a few years. It follows you.
That's the kind of thing that sounds almost too harsh to be true, but it is completely true, and people find out the hard way.
And the COBRA situation is not the only wrinkle at retirement. If you're 65 and still working, with a spouse on your employer plan who's younger, there's real math to do. Ian walks through whether you keep the family plan or move yourself to Medicare, and it includes this income-related surcharge called IRMAA.
Explain that because I know people hear that word and their eyes glaze over.
So Medicare's standard Part B premium, the baseline, is $202.90 a month in 2026. But if your income is above certain thresholds, Medicare adds a surcharge on top of that. And here's the kicker: they're not looking at what you made this year. They're looking at your tax return from two years earlier.
That far back. So if you had a great run two back, you're paying for it now.
Exactly. A lot of people retire, their income drops, and they still get hit with IRMAA for a year or two because of prior income. There are ways to appeal it if your situation has genuinely changed, but our advisors know the specifics of that process much better than I'd want to summarize here. That's a great question to bring to them.
Write that one down if you're in that situation. Okay, there's another wrinkle in this section that honestly surprised me, the Health Savings Account thing.
If you're still contributing to an HSA and you sign up for Medicare, even just Part A, you have to stop contributing. If you don't, you've made excess contributions, and the tax consequences are not pleasant.
So two things that feel like they should go together, putting new money into a health savings account and being on Medicare, can't coexist once you enroll.
That's the rule. And Ian flags it because people who love their HSAs sometimes delay enrollment specifically to keep contributing, which is a legitimate strategy, but it has its own timing considerations. The details there are really worth a direct conversation with one of our advisors.
Let's talk about the small employer situation because I don't think people realize the rules flip.
This one surprises almost everyone. If your company has fewer than 20 employees, Medicare generally pays first, not your work plan. So if you're 65, working at a small company, and you haven't signed up for Part B, you could be getting bills that your work plan has no obligation to cover.
Because the work plan expects Medicare to have already paid its share, and Medicare isn't there.
Right. The plan designed itself around being secondary. If the primary payer isn't there, nobody's covering that gap.
Okay, I want to get to the snowbird section because I feel like half of Arizona is affected by this one.
Ha. Probably more than half. So Medicare Advantage, which a lot of people are on, is built around counties. Your plan covers you in your plan's service area. Leave that area for more than six months, and generally the plan is required to drop you.
Drop you, as in you lose coverage?
You lose that plan. And Ian makes a distinction that matters: visiting somewhere is not the same as moving there. So if you spend summers somewhere else, you're not establishing residency, but you are potentially outside your coverage area for a long stretch.
And Original Medicare doesn't have this problem.
It has no county line. If a provider accepts it, you're covered, wherever you are. That's the structural difference.
For someone who splits their time, that's not a small thing. That's potentially the whole decision.
It can be. And it connects to a point Ian makes throughout the series: the job you're leaving, the letter on the counter, where you spend winter, these can turn out to be one decision instead of three. A planner who sees all eighteen situations at once can spot those connections before they become problems.
Let's get to the thing that I flagged immediately when I read this, the observation stay issue. Because when I first heard about this, I couldn't believe it was real.
It's this trap where you can spend three nights in a hospital bed, you're in a hospital gown, you're getting care, you're being monitored, and technically you are an outpatient.
While in a bed. For three days.
Because the hospital classified you as under observation rather than admitted. And those three nights, even though you experienced them as a hospital stay, do not count toward the three inpatient days that Original Medicare requires before it covers a skilled nursing facility.
So you get out of the hospital, you need rehab, and then you find out Medicare won't cover it because those nights didn't count.
And that bill can be significant. Ian says the facility is required to give you a notice about your status, and he names the one question to ask while you're still in the bed.
Ask whether you've been admitted or whether you're under observation. Those are different things, and you have the right to know.
Don't wait until discharge. That's the whole point of that section.
I want to talk about the Advantage to Supplement door-locking situation, because I think this is one that people really don't see coming.
This one is worth slowing down on. Medicare Advantage lets you switch plans every fall during Open Enrollment, no health questions, no underwriting. Medicare Supplements, the plans that wrap around Original Medicare, generally do require underwriting if you're not in your initial enrollment window.
So you can always go from Supplement to Advantage easily enough, but going back the other way...
That can be very hard. Ian's number is striking: nine in ten enrollees have no guaranteed right to buy a Supplement later. So if you're on that plan, feel fine, and assume you can switch if you ever need more coverage, that assumption might not hold.
Nine out of ten. That's not a fringe situation.
That's most people on Advantage. And the door can lock at a moment when you have already become someone who needs a lot of coverage. That's the worst time to find out you can't get a Supplement.
Okay, the drug plan penalty deserves a minute too, because the logic of it is so counterintuitive.
If you're healthy and you don't take any prescriptions, skipping a drug plan feels completely rational. Why pay for something you're not using?
And the answer is...
The penalty grows every month you go without coverage. And it's permanent. So the person who skips Part D for five years and then develops a condition where they suddenly need prescriptions is now paying a penalty on top of the premium, sized by those five years, for as long as they have Medicare drug coverage.
For being healthy all that time. That is a strange way to design a system.
I didn't put it together. I'm just reporting on it.
Ha. Let's do the letter situation, because September and October are apparently letter season.
Two letters that can show up and look similar. One says your plan is changing for next year. The other says your plan is going away. And they are not the same thing.
Because if it's the one that's ending, you have different rights and different deadlines.
Right. Ian's piece on that, which is part six, shows specifically how to tell the two apart. Part seven goes deeper and reads the Annual Notice of Change like a spec sheet, including two cost measurements that people routinely confuse. And part eighteen is fascinating because it shows how to use an AI assistant to help read the same letter.
I want to come back to the AI stuff in a second, but the phone call section, can we do that? Because October is also apparently when the phones start ringing.
Ian is very direct about this: Medicare says it will never call to sell you anything. Federal rules bar cold calls from plans and agents who don't already have your permission. So if a call comes in during Open Enrollment from someone saying they're with Medicare and they have a plan for you, that call is not what it claims to be.
And Ian gives two sentences he actually says before he hangs up.
He does. I'd say read part seventeen for those, because they're worth having ready.
Okay, the AI section. Ian describes himself as an engineer who uses an AI assistant every day, and he's written three parts on this. What's the actual useful thing to take away?
Part fourteen might be the one to bookmark, because it lists seven things no AI can know about your Medicare. Because they're not public yet, or they're public only county by county or state by state, or they exist only in your own file.
So AI can help you understand a concept, but it can't tell you what your plan's formulary says or what's available in your specific area.
Exactly. And part eighteen shows five prompts to type in order when reading your Annual Notice of Change with an AI, plus what not to paste in, and the three questions the assistant simply cannot answer from that letter. It's a very practical framework.
There's also a piece on something called WISeR, which I had never heard of before.
It's a federal pilot program that now reviews prior authorization requests for a specific list of services in Original Medicare in six states, and Arizona is one of them. The rules require that a human clinician review every denial. Ian covers what to do if a request stalls.
So if you're in Arizona and you're in Original Medicare and you've had one of those stuck in the system, that's worth knowing about.
Part fifteen is the one to read for that.
Let me bring up the military and veteran pieces because I don't want to skip those, even quickly.
Two important ones. For veterans with VA care, the VA and Medicare don't coordinate. Outside the VA system, you're on Original Medicare, and Original Medicare Part B pays 80 percent of covered services with no cap on what you could owe in a year. Part three covers how an Advantage plan can add a yearly out-of-pocket maximum, though availability varies by county.
And for military retirees with TRICARE For Life?
It has no premium of its own and covers what Medicare leaves behind. But it requires Part B, and Part B at the 2026 standard rate is $202.90 a month. It also means you generally don't need a separate drug plan, because it handles that.
So the premium isn't zero, it's the Part B premium.
Right. No cost of its own, but Part B is the bill. That distinction matters when you're budgeting.
Alright, the piece ends with what Ian calls what a Certified Medicare Planner does differently, and it's a pretty good summary of why all of this complexity matters.
That's really what it comes down to. Most of us run into these situations one at a time, usually for the first time, usually in a hurry. A planner has walked families through every single one of them and knows how they connect. All those pieces we were just describing, the ones that feel like separate conversations, they can turn out to be a single decision once somebody's looking at the whole picture.
One thing with a lot of parts hiding inside it.
And Ian's suggestion is straightforward: find your situation in the series, bring that part to the conversation, and start there.
There's also a workshop. In person, which I think is great.
Friday, October 2nd. Two locations. Foothills Library in Glendale at 10:30 in the morning, and Mustang Library in Scottsdale at 2:30 in the afternoon. No cost to attend.
You can register at 123easymedicare.com/medicare-workshop, or call 877-220-1089. And if you'd rather just talk to someone directly, the team at American Retirement Advisors is at 602-281-3898.
That's the number to call if you want to sit down with a team that sees all eighteen of these situations at once and knows how yours connect.
Medicare is one of those things where the cost of not knowing shows up later, and usually at the worst moment. So if any part of today's conversation made you think, wait, that might be me, please don't just file it away. Find that part of Ian's series, bring it to an advisor, and get the actual answer for your actual situation. That's what they're there for, and it's a lot less stressful than finding out on the other end of a bill. Thank you so much for spending this time with us today.