The Lobster Roll Trail, Part 2: Cash Only in Harpswell, Sunrise on Cadillac Mountain
July 12, 2026
Listen Now
Subscribe
Ready to talk with an advisor?
The advisors at American Retirement Advisors have been having these conversations for over 25 years. A no-cost discovery session is the fastest way to find out where you actually stand.
Schedule a Discovery Session
Show Notes
Eddie and Betty's Conversation
Welcome back to The American Retirement Advisor. I am so glad you are here with us today. Eddie is in the studio with me, as always, and we have got something a little different for you this episode. We have been following a series written by Ian Schaeffer, our company's COO, and it is ostensibly a lobster roll road trip up the coast of Maine, but there is this one moment near the end where it stops being about food entirely. And when I read it I set my coffee down and just sat with it for a minute. Eddie, I think this one is going to resonate with a lot of our listeners.
Yeah, and I appreciate you framing it that way because when you first told me it was a lobster roll article I was ready to be charmed and then move on. But Ian Schaeffer has a way of slipping the real thing in through the side door. You are reading about butter and picnic tables and suddenly you are thinking about the last forty years of your working life. So let's take people through it.
Let's do it. So this is part two of the series. Part one took us from a shack on Plum Island up through Kennebunkport. Part two picks up at stop five, which is a place called Erica's Seafood out in Harpswell, Maine, and I want to start there because the description alone is worth reading. He takes you down this two-lane road through pine trees, water flashing between the trunks, and the peninsula keeps narrowing until, as he puts it, you are fairly sure you are driving off the end of the world.
And at the end of that road is this small shack with a hand-painted sign, run by a family, Tom Butler and Andrea Hunter and their daughter Erica. Cash only, no drinks sold, closed on Wednesdays. And the roll itself is just lobster on a roll with sea salt butter on the side. No mayo, no celery, no seasoning. That's the whole thing.
Which somehow sounds like the most perfect thing I have ever heard. But what got me was the way he describes sitting there. He says it is the quietest stop on the trail. Water on three sides, time on all of them. And he tells you to take the walk out to the point before you leave.
There is something intentional about recommending the quiet stop. The previous stops, he notes, had crowds and gift shops. This one has nothing to sell you. And I think that contrast is doing some work for the larger point he is building toward, even if you do not see it yet.
Right, it is almost like he is teaching you to slow down before the bigger lesson lands. So from Harpswell you head two hours up the coast to Camden. And Camden is where I think the article really starts to shift.
Camden is a gorgeous stop. He describes it as where the mountains meet the sea, eight hundred feet of mountain rising directly behind the harbor, the Megunticook River running right through downtown, and a harbor full of historic schooners. He mentions the Lewis R. French as one of the oldest commercial sailing vessels in America, and the Olad, which was built in 1927 and still takes passengers out in season.
A boat built in 1927 still carrying passengers. That is something. But his actual recommendation for Camden does not cost anything. There are thirty memorial benches along the public landing, and he says just take one. Sit there. Listen to the halyards clanging against the masts.
And sooner or later somebody sits down on the other end of the bench. Maybe they retired five years ago, maybe they are about to, maybe they never quite will. And you have the kind of conversation with a stranger you have not had since college. That line hit me.
It hit me too. Because that kind of conversation, the unhurried kind where you are not watching the clock, that is one of the things people say they are looking forward to in retirement. And they imagine they will have it all the time. But sometimes people get there and they do not know how to give themselves permission to just sit on a bench.
Which is right where Ian Schaeffer drops in this observation from the advisor side of the table. He writes that the people who are happiest in retirement are not the ones who found the perfect hobby. They are the ones who stopped apologizing for enjoying their own life. And he says you can spot them on the benches in Camden because they are not checking their phones.
That stopped me cold when I read it. Stopped apologizing for enjoying their own life. How many people do we know who have worked hard their whole careers and still feel like they need to justify taking a slow morning or a long lunch?
It is more common than people think. And it is not just a personality quirk. There is a real psychological dimension to the transition from accumulating to spending. You spend decades in a mindset where saving is virtue and spending is suspect. Flipping that switch when you finally have permission is genuinely hard for a lot of people.
So Camden gives us that emotional core. And then the article shifts to stop seven, Cadillac Mountain, but there is a practical section first about reservations. And I appreciated this because Ian Schaeffer is meticulous. He says yes, you do need a timed vehicle reservation to drive up Cadillac Mountain, from late May through late October, and the sunrise window is the one that sells out.
The reservations come from recreation.gov. Thirty percent of the slots open ninety days ahead, the other seventy percent open two days ahead, both at ten in the morning Eastern time. The total cost is six dollars plus a four dollar processing fee, ten dollars total, on top of your park pass. He says to set an alarm for the release the same way you would for concert tickets.
Which tells you something about how competitive those sunrise slots get. You are setting an alarm like it is Taylor Swift tickets, but you are going to watch the sun come up over the Atlantic Ocean.
And he gives you the honest footnote too, which I love about his writing. He says people will tell you Cadillac Mountain is the first place in America to see the sunrise, and he goes out of his way to verify that. The answer is nuanced. In July it technically is not the first. That honor belongs to Mars Hill, about a hundred and fifty miles northeast. Cadillac holds the title from early October to early March.
He notes that around here they verify things even on fun weekends. Which is such a good line.
It is. And then he asks whether any of that matters when the horizon goes from indigo to amber and the sun breaks over the Atlantic while four hundred strangers hold their breath at the same time. And his answer is not even a little.
Cadillac is the highest point on the Atlantic coast of the United States, fifteen hundred and thirty feet of bare pink granite above Bar Harbor. And he tells you that to get the sunrise you will wake up at three thirty in the morning on vacation. He acknowledges that sounds insane. The line of headlights snaking up the mountain in the dark also sounds insane. And he says do it anyway.
What he describes at the top is worth the buildup. The dawn lasts about two minutes. Somebody gasps, somebody claps, and then it goes quiet. Within ten minutes most of the crowd heads down for blueberry pancakes and you have the summit nearly to yourself. Bar Harbor sitting below you like a model village, the islands scattered across Frenchman Bay, the whole coastline you just spent two days eating your way up, laid out in the morning light.
And that image, standing on top of a mountain looking back at the whole journey you just made, that is where the article makes its turn. Because the next section is called what was all the saving for. And that is the serious question he promised at the beginning.
This is the part that earns everything that came before it. He asks you to add up the entire trail, every lobster roll from Newbury to Bar Harbor, the gas, three nights in decent hotels, the gift shop, the ten dollar sunrise reservation. For two people, all of it, well under a thousand dollars.
Under a thousand dollars for two people. That is a real number. And his observation is that most of the people who sit down with advisors could fund that trip out of one month's interest and never notice it.
And yet he says the hardest conversation in retirement planning is not about markets or taxes. It is convincing someone who saved diligently for four decades that they are now allowed to spend some of it on a thirty dollar sandwich without feeling like they did something wrong.
A thirty dollar sandwich. That is what a really great lobster roll costs, and people who have been careful and disciplined for their whole working lives can sit down in front of one and feel guilty.
It sounds almost silly when you say it out loud, but it is real. The discipline that helped them build a retirement is the same discipline that, if left unchecked, makes them unable to enjoy it. And that is not a character flaw. It is the natural outcome of forty years of conditioning.
He names that conditioning directly. He says you packed the lunches, you ate at your desk, you drove past places like these for forty years on the way to somewhere you had to be.
That is such a specific, true image. Driving past a harbor town on the way to a meeting. Seeing a sign for a scenic overlook and not taking the exit because you did not have time. You told yourself you would get there eventually. That was the whole deal.
And then Ian Schaeffer writes this, and I am going to quote it closely because I do not want to paraphrase it away. He says the plan was never just to have money. The plan was to prepare what you have, protect it, and then make sure it lasts as long as you do, and the last part of that sentence is you. Living.
The last part of that sentence is you. Living. That is the whole thing right there.
He lists it out almost like a declaration. At a picnic table at the end of a peninsula, on a bench in Camden, on top of a mountain at five in the morning. Those are not frivolous activities. Those are what the plan was for.
And I think what he is doing with the specific geography matters too. He is not saying go be extravagant. The most expensive thing on this list is the hotel nights. The lobster rolls, the bench in Camden, the sunrise on Cadillac Mountain, these are modest pleasures. Under a thousand dollars for two people. He is not making the case for reckless spending. He is making the case for spending at all, on things that actually matter to you.
Which is a conversation people should have with someone who can help them figure out what that looks like in their specific situation. Because there is a real planning question underneath the emotional one. How do you build a spending plan that lets you enjoy your retirement without legitimately running out? Those are different problems.
They are different problems, and the answers depend on your income sources, your expenses, how long you plan to work, what your health picture looks like, whether you have a pension or Social Security timing to work through. The exact mechanics of how you build that sustainable spending plan are really questions for one of our advisors at American Retirement Advisors, not a podcast. What we can do is name the problem clearly, which is what Ian Schaeffer does with real clarity.
He really does. And then he ends with this: Monday we will be back to the serious work. This weekend, go find your lobster roll.
Which is both a permission slip and a challenge. Do you know where your lobster roll is? Do you know the thing you have been driving past for forty years?
I love that he made it tangible and not abstract. It is not go live your best life. It is go drive to the end of a peninsula in Maine and bring cash.
Cash only, closed Wednesdays, no ATM at the end of the peninsula. Bring your own drinks. The specificity is the whole charm of the piece. He is not dealing in generalities. And I think that is why the financial point lands. He earned it with the details.
There is also a postscript at the end where he mentions he is working on a novel. The husband in the story just ate at Bob Lobster and apparently has no idea what is about to happen to him in Harpswell. Working title still to be determined.
Which, given that Harpswell is where you find Erica's Seafood at the end of a narrowing peninsula with water on all sides, I think that husband is in for something good. At least culinarily.
I want to circle back to one thing before we wrap up, because I think it deserves more than just a mention. The phrase he uses, the hardest conversation is convincing someone who saved diligently that they are now allowed to spend, that word allowed is doing a lot of work. People feel like they need permission.
And in some ways they do, not permission in a parental sense, but confirmation. Confirmation that the math works, that they are not going to outlive what they have, that spending this month does not compromise next year. That is a real and legitimate need. The emotional permission is one piece. The financial confidence is the other. And you can not get to full enjoyment without both.
So when people sit down with an advisor and say I feel guilty spending money, that is not just a soft feeling to be patted away. That is a signal that they need a clearer picture of what sustainable looks like for them specifically.
Right. And when somebody has that picture, when they have run the numbers and they understand their income floor and they know what they can spend without eroding what needs to last, that is when you can sit on the bench in Camden without your phone out. The guilt does not come from weakness. It comes from uncertainty. Clarity is the cure.
Clarity is the cure. That is a good bumper sticker. I also want to touch briefly on something the article gestures at when it says protect what you have, because that is a whole world of planning that is easy to gloss over when we are talking about spending and enjoying retirement.
Right, he uses that sequence, prepare what you have, protect it, and then make sure it lasts as long as you do. The protecting piece is real. In the retirement years that can mean a lot of different things. How you protect a portfolio from sequence of returns risk is different from how you protect a legacy for your family. And those are conversations with different tools and different timelines.
When you get into legacy and protecting what passes to the next generation, that is where insurance planning shows up in a different way than it did when people were younger and working, right? Because early in life, when you have kids and a mortgage and a spouse depending on your income, term coverage makes sense. It is cost-effective protection for the years when people need it most. But those later-life goals, leaving something for the family, covering estate costs, treating heirs equitably, those generally call for coverage that lasts as long as you do.
That is an important distinction and one people sometimes miss. Term coverage is temporary by design. It is built to protect income during the years dependents rely on it, and it does that job well. But if the goal is something that needs to be there regardless of when you pass, thirty years from now, forty years from now, you need coverage that does not expire. The structure is fundamentally different, the underwriting is different, the planning around it is different. If you are thinking about that kind of planning specifically, the right move is to sit down with someone who can look at your full picture. I would write that question down and bring it to one of our advisors, because the details really do matter there.
And the beautiful thing about Ian Schaeffer's piece is that it reminds you why any of that planning matters in the first place. You are not doing it to have a tidy spreadsheet. You are doing it so that the person you love, or the kids you raised, or the cause you care about, has what it needs. And so that you, in the meantime, can watch the boat that caught your lunch head back out for tomorrow's.
That image keeps coming back to me. Sitting at a painted picnic table at the end of a peninsula, watching a working lobster boat go back out. There is something about that combination of simple pleasure and real life continuing around you that feels exactly like what retirement should be.
And it does not require a million dollar lifestyle. That is the other thing. He is not describing a luxury trip. He is describing a trip that two people can take for under a thousand dollars. The barriers are not mostly financial. They are psychological. They are the permission problem.
Which comes back to the bench in Camden. He says the happiest retirees stopped apologizing for enjoying their own life. That is not a financial skill. That is a mindset shift. But a good financial plan supports it, because when you are not anxious about the numbers, you can actually be present on the bench.
Not checking your phone.
Not checking your phone.
So let me ask you this, because I think it is the practical question hiding under all of this. If someone is listening right now and they recognize themselves in the guilty-about-the-sandwich person, what is the first step?
The first step is getting honest about what the picture really looks like. A lot of the guilt comes from not knowing. People have a vague fear that spending now means running out later, and rather than confront that fear directly they just default to not spending. The antidote to vague fear is specific clarity. Sit down with someone, look at your income sources, your timeline, your actual needs versus your anxiety-driven assumptions, and build a spending framework you can trust. Once you know what your sustainable spending looks like, the thirty dollar sandwich stops feeling dangerous.
And if you do not have that picture yet, or if you have not revisited it recently, that is exactly the conversation to have with an advisor. Not because anything is wrong, but because you deserve to know that things are okay. You did the work. You packed the lunches. You drove past the scenic overlooks. At some point you get to take the exit.
That is what Ian Schaeffer's piece is really about, and I am so grateful he wrote it. If you are listening and this resonated, I hope you will reach out to us at American Retirement Advisors and have that conversation. Not because your plan is broken, but because you have earned the right to know it is working, and to go find your lobster roll. Thank you so much for spending this time with us. We will see you next episode.