Plan letter came. What can you change? Take-Home Notes, part three
September 30, 2026
Listen Now
Subscribe
Ready to talk with an advisor?
The advisors at American Retirement Advisors have been having these conversations for over 25 years. A no-cost discovery session is the fastest way to find out where you actually stand.
Schedule a Discovery Session
Show Notes
Eddie and Betty's Conversation
Welcome back to The American Retirement Advisor. I'm here with Eddie, as always, and we are talking Medicare today, specifically the enrollment windows, which sounds boring until you realize missing the wrong one can cost you real money or lock you out of coverage you actually wanted.
Yeah, and I'll say right up front, I thought I had a pretty solid handle on this topic, and Ian Schaeffer's piece still had a moment that made me go, wait, that's not how I thought that worked.
So we're starting from scratch for the listener who just got a letter in the mail, because Ian's article opens right there, September 30, which is apparently the day Medicare's mailing guide says people will have their notice from their current plan about next year.
The letter is open, four words are circled, and the question becomes what do I do now. And what Ian's piece does really well is lay out the four enrollment windows, because most people only know about one.
Okay, walk me through the four because I can never keep them straight and I am absolutely the person who thinks there's just one big window every fall.
You and about half the country. So the first one is your Initial Enrollment period, seven months centered on your 65th birthday month. That one is yours alone, nobody else shares it.
Just for me. Okay.
Then there's Annual Enrollment, October 15 to December 7, which is the one you see advertised constantly on TV. That's when you change your plan for next year, and changes take effect January 1.
That's the one with the celebrities telling you to call an 800 number before the deadline, right?
Every single commercial break. Then there's a second Open Enrollment, January 1 to March 31, but that one is only for people already on a Medicare Advantage plan who want to make one change.
Just one total for the whole window?
One change. And then the fourth is Special Enrollment, which kicks in when a life event happens. You move, you lose coverage, you leave your employer plan.
Okay, so here's where Ian's article has this line that the presenters are told to say loudly, and I want you to say it loudly too.
Ha. Okay. If you are turning 65 or leaving an employer plan, you have your own window, and the enrollment period you see advertised on TV does not apply to you.
Say it again.
The commercials are not for you. You have your own separate window. Do not sit around waiting for October 15 if you are turning 65, because that is not your deadline.
This is the thing that I think trips people up the most. Someone turns 65, they hear all the TV noise about Annual Enrollment, and they think they missed it or they need to wait for it. But those two things are completely separate, and confusing them is where the real trouble starts.
Either mistake can cost them. Missing your Initial Enrollment window has consequences. The article doesn't go deep into penalties here, and the exact rules there are a question for one of our advisors, but the point is your deadline is not October 15, so don't treat it like it is.
Alright, so let's say I'm the person who IS in that window. What can I change?
Three things you can do. Swap your Part D drug plan, swap your Medicare Advantage plan, or switch between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage in either direction.
So I can go from one to the other and back again?
Right, and Medicare's own handbook, Medicare and You 2027, says it that way. Join, switch, or drop an Advantage plan or drug plan, or switch to Original Medicare. And no health questions for any of those three changes.
That's a big deal.
During that window, yes. Which is why what comes next in the article is the part that makes people sit up, because it is very much not the same story for Medicare Supplements.
Okay, so I've heard those called Medigap plans. Same thing?
Yep, that's right. And here's where it gets interesting. Your Supplement doesn't wait for October. You can apply to change it any month of the year.
Wait, really? That sounds way more flexible.
Until you read the next line. Health questions may apply.
Oh.
Yeah. Outside your first six months on Part B, a Supplement company can generally ask about your health before it accepts you or sets your price. The handbook is direct about it: after that window, you may not be able to buy a Medigap policy, or it may cost more.
So the door is technically open year-round but it might not open for you specifically depending on your health history.
That's the right picture. And Ian's piece mentions that Nevada has a protection Arizona doesn't have on this, which the team wrote a whole separate article about. So if you're in one of those states, the details matter, and I'd write that down and ask one of our advisors what applies where you live.
There's also a thing in the article about switching FROM an Advantage plan back to Original Medicare during Annual Enrollment being always allowed, but then getting a Supplement to go with it is not always guaranteed.
Which is the kind of thing that catches people off guard. You make the switch, you're back on Original Medicare, you want a Supplement to fill the gaps, and then, hello, health questions.
So the plan you made in the fall doesn't automatically come with the pieces you assumed you'd get.
Right. The switch is allowed. The Supplement is a separate application with a separate set of rules.
Okay, what about the person who reads this and thinks, you know what, I don't want to deal with any of this, I'll just do nothing.
Usually fine, if you've read your letter. Your plan rolls over, next year's version of it starts January 1. The handbook's language on this is kind of funny because it's so matter of fact.
What does it say?
It says, if you kept your existing coverage and your plan's costs or benefits changed, those changes also start January 1. Meaning you didn't choose nothing. You chose whatever the new version of your plan is.
Which could be fine or could be a surprise depending on whether you read the letter.
Exactly. And Ian makes a point I really liked: if every answer after reading your letter is no, I don't want to change anything, that's a decision too, and a good one to make on purpose.
Not by accident.
There's a big difference between deciding to stay and just not getting around to it.
Now there's one scenario where doing nothing really isn't fine.
If your letter says the plan won't be offered next year. That's a completely different situation, and the article notes there are specific rights that come with that letter. So if that's what yours says, do not put it back in the envelope.
Two letters with very different implications. Got it.
They mean completely opposite things. One says here's what's changing, the other says we're leaving, and you've got to respond to each one in its own way.
Alright, let's talk about the second chance question, because I think people don't know this exists. What happens after January 1 if you're on Advantage and you feel like you made the wrong call?
Same handbook, same rulebook -- you get one more shot at it. Runs through March 31. You can move into a different plan, or do exactly what we described a moment ago, that full pivot back to the traditional side of Medicare, and pick up a standalone drug plan to go with it.
And when does that change kick in?
First day of the month after your plan gets the request. So not January 1 necessarily, it depends on when you submit it.
But if you're on Original Medicare with just a drug plan, that window isn't available to you.
Correct. Which is one more reason the article pushes hard on using it well. If you're on that plan, October 15 to December 7 is your main event.
So let me just play this back the way someone with the letter in front of them should think about it.
Please.
Step one, figure out which window is yours. Are you turning 65? Is something changing in your life like a job or a move? Or are you in the big Annual Enrollment boat with everyone else.
And Ian's article has the best homework assignment for this. On your notes sheet, write, My window, and fill it in. Most readers it's October 15 to December 7, but not everyone.
Then underneath that, jot down the three changes you could make during Annual Enrollment, and next to each one, yes or no, do I want to make this change.
Drug plan, Advantage plan, or switch my whole path between Original Medicare and Advantage. Three questions, yes or no.
I love that it's that simple on paper. The complication is knowing what your options are within each of those choices.
Which is why the workshops exist. Ian's piece is written around a specific event, two sessions on Friday October 2, one at Foothills Library in Glendale at 10:30 in the morning, one at Mustang Library in Scottsdale at 2:30 in the afternoon.
At no cost to you, and you can register at 123easymedicare.com slash medicare-workshop or call 877-220-1089.
And if you have questions before Friday, the advisors are available at 602-281-3898.
There's also something Ian teases at the very end of the article that I want to mention because it made me laugh.
The tooth icon.
The little icon on Medicare.gov that, quote, does not say what you think. Which, same honestly.
The October 1 plan search switches to 2027 data, and apparently there's a whole walkthrough in the next installment, doctors, drugs, and whatever the tooth icon actually means.
Which we will not spoil because we don't know yet.
Accurate.
Alright, here's my close. If you opened a letter this week, or if you've been ignoring one on the counter because you're not sure what to do with it, this is the episode that says go read it. Figure out your window. Answer three yes or no questions. And if the answer to any of them is yes, or if you're just not sure, that's what the advisors at American Retirement Advisors are there for. Sit down with one. The conversation is a lot shorter when you've already got the letter open and you know which window you're in.
And if you're in the Phoenix area, Friday's workshop is a great way to do this in a room with other people asking the same questions. There's something useful about hearing someone else ask the thing you were embarrassed to ask.
Not that either of us would know anything about that.
I ask embarrassing questions professionally at this point.
You really do. Thanks for listening, everybody. Ian Schaeffer's full article has the enrollment windows defined in detail, including links to the specific pieces on Medigap rules by state and what to do if your plan is leaving. We'll see you next time.