Discount plan or dental insurance?
October 29, 2026
Listen Now
Subscribe
Ready to talk with an advisor?
The advisors at American Retirement Advisors have been having these conversations for over 25 years. A no-cost discovery session is the fastest way to find out where you actually stand.
Schedule a Discovery Session
Show Notes
Eddie and Betty's Conversation
Welcome to The American Retirement Advisor. I'm Betty, and Eddie is here with me in the studio today, which means we are about to get into some actual numbers, so buckle up.
I was going to say something humble and self-deprecating but you pretty much covered it.
We're talking about dental coverage today, specifically the piece Ian Schaeffer just published, and I want to start with something he said right at the top that I think a lot of people don't realize.
Which is that this has changed. For years the advisors here were basically telling clients, be careful with dental policies, they're expensive and they barely cover anything beyond cleanings and X-rays. That advice has shifted because some plans now actually pay meaningful benefits.
Right, but Ian's point isn't just, go get a dental plan. His point is that signing up for a policy isn't even necessarily your best move. And he lays out the two main options people are actually weighing: a dental discount plan, or dental insurance.
And they are very different things.
Okay, so let's start with the one I had honestly never heard explained clearly before. What is a dental discount plan?
So it is not insurance. That's the first thing to understand. You pay a yearly or monthly fee, you get access to a network of dentists who have agreed to charge you reduced prices, and then you pay the dentist directly. The plan pays the dentist nothing.
It's basically a membership card.
That's a pretty good way to put it. No deductibles, no waiting periods, no yearly maximums, no claim forms. You just show up, you pay the discounted rate, you go home.
And what does the membership card cost?
Ian found prices in 2026 running roughly eighty to a hundred and eighty-five dollars a year for one person. And the advertised discounts are typically between ten and fifty percent.
That's a wide range.
It is, and the big watch-out he flags is that the discount only applies at participating dentists. So before you sign up for anything, check that your dentist is actually in the network.
Because if it doesn't work with yours, you've got a discount plan that discounts nothing.
You paid a hundred and fifty dollars for a card your dentist will not accept. Yes.
He also mentioned something about Nevada versus Arizona in the article, and I want to make sure people catch that.
So the difference is pretty stark. Nevada requires these plans to register with the Division of Insurance and to state clearly that they are not insurance. Arizona doesn't regulate them the same way. So if you're in Arizona, you really need to read the terms yourself. Nobody's doing that disclosure for you automatically.
Which is a little bit wild when you think about it, because someone could genuinely think they bought insurance when they didn't.
And that is a very unpleasant thing to discover when you're sitting in the dentist's chair.
Okay, so that's the discount plan. Now let's talk about actual dental insurance, because this is where it gets more complicated.
So it works the way most people expect coverage to work. The plan pays part of the cost of covered care, usually after a deductible, up to a yearly maximum. And there are a few terms that really decide how much help you actually get.
Walk me through that piece, because I feel like it's one that surprises people.
Most plans cap what they'll pay in a year somewhere between a thousand and twenty-five hundred dollars. So if you need a lot of work done, there's a ceiling on how much the insurance company is going to chip in.
And dental work can get expensive fast.
A single crown can be over a thousand dollars. So that maximum can matter a lot.
What about waiting periods? Ian mentions those and I feel like they are the sneaky thing that catches people.
That's what I'd most want someone to understand before they sign up. Often six to twelve months before the plan will cover basic or major work. Cleanings and exams usually covered right away, but the bigger stuff, you may be waiting.
So you sign up in January hoping that crown will go through, and if there's a twelve-month waiting period, you're looking at January of next year.
And if you need that crown in March, you are paying for it yourself on top of the premiums you've already been paying.
Which is the exact scenario Ian models out in the article, right? That's the example that stopped me.
Let's get into that because it is genuinely striking. He builds a hypothetical: one person, one year, two routine visits and one crown needed. And he runs the same situation three ways.
Okay, what are the numbers?
Pay cash for everything, you're at seventeen hundred dollars for the year. Go with a discount plan at a hundred and fifty dollars a year with twenty percent off, you land at fifteen hundred and ten. Now here's the one that got me.
The insurance scenarios.
Same policy, forty dollars a month, covers cleanings fully, covers major work at fifty percent after a fifty dollar deductible. If the crown lands in month three, inside the waiting period, you pay all thirteen hundred dollars of it yourself, plus your premiums all year. Total: seventeen hundred and eighty dollars.
That's more than paying cash.
That's the out-of-pocket reality. But wait, same policy, same person, same crown, except now it's month thirteen. Waiting period's over. The plan pays half. Total drops to eleven hundred and fifty-five dollars.
So the same insurance policy is either your best option or your worst option depending entirely on timing?
Six hundred and twenty-five dollar difference. Same policy. The only variable is when the crown happened.
That is kind of a jaw-dropping illustration.
And Ian's clear that these are hypothetical numbers, your dentist's fees and your plan's terms are going to be different. But the pattern is real.
So the discount plan won in the first-year scenario. Came in under cash, no waiting period drama.
And the lesson Ian draws is pretty straightforward: a discount plan works from day one. Insurance tends to pay off when major work is likely, but likely after the waiting period. If you're expecting a big procedure soon, insurance in year one might actually cost you more.
There's also this point in the article about just paying cash, which I think people dismiss too fast.
If all you're doing is two cleanings a year and nothing else, insurance premiums can outpace what you'd spend just paying as you go. Ian's framing is: with only routine care, cash or a discount plan often wins.
I also want to flag the PPO versus HMO piece because he mentions it and I know people get confused by that alphabet soup.
Quick version: a dental PPO lets you see any dentist but pays more when you stay in network. A dental HMO requires you to use its network, usually has set copays, often no yearly maximum, and generally costs less. The tradeoff is flexibility.
And he's got a note about implants and crowns and dentures specifically, which I think is worth flagging.
Same rule applies here as it did with the network check -- do your homework first. Read the fine print on exactly how those are covered, because how a plan handles a crown or an implant varies a lot between policies, and that is often the most expensive work people end up needing.
So how does someone actually run their own version of this comparison? Because Ian does give a practical framework.
Start with your own dentist. A lot of dentists offer a cash discount if you ask. Some have in-office membership plans for routine care at a flat yearly fee. Then ask for a written treatment plan with prices before anything starts. Once you have actual numbers from your actual dentist, you can run your own version of the comparison.
Which is so much more useful than comparing plans in the abstract.
Because that math doesn't tell you what your dentist charges for a crown. Your dentist's office does.
He also points to 123EasyDental.com for comparing individual dental plans and prices, and I want to be clear about what he says there.
He's upfront that they're licensed to offer some of those, not all of them, and that the point is to help you compare, not to push you toward any particular one.
There's also a full side-by-side guide, Dental Care in Retirement, that goes into the fine print. And if you want to talk through your specific situation, the number in the article is 602-281-3898.
For anything that gets into the specifics of your health, your expected dental work, your current dentist, that's a conversation worth having with an advisor. The article gives you the framework but the variables are personal.
What I keep thinking about is how many people just default to buying insurance because it sounds like the responsible thing to do, without running any of this.
And for some people, depending on timing and what they need, it is the right call. But for others, they're literally paying more for coverage than they would have paid with no coverage at all.
Which is exactly the kind of thing that should be on the table before you make the decision, not after.
The comparison that Ian built in this article took me maybe three minutes to read through. The homework of actually pulling your dentist's fee list and a treatment plan takes a little longer, but it's the work that makes the decision real.
And this is part two of a five-part series on dental care in retirement, so there's a lot more coming. Ian's next piece gets into where to actually find lower-cost dental care in the Phoenix area and Las Vegas.
Which, if you live in either of those places, is probably very useful information.
To summarize where we landed: a discount plan isn't insurance, but it can be genuinely cheaper than insurance if you need work done soon. Insurance can win, but only if you time it right relative to the waiting period. And if you're mostly doing routine care, the math may just favor paying cash.
Three very different answers to the same question, all potentially correct depending on your situation.
Which is why the individual comparison matters so much. If you want help thinking through the specifics, sit down with one of the advisors at American Retirement Advisors. Bring your dentist's numbers, bring your treatment plan if you have one, and let someone help you run the math for your actual situation. That's what they're there for.