Did your plan add a deductible? What the Letter Leaves Out, part one | The American Retirement Advisor PodcastSkip to main content
HomePodcastEpisode 225

Did your plan add a deductible? What the Letter Leaves Out, part one

October 5, 2026

Show Notes

Eddie and Betty's Conversation

Betty

Welcome to The American Retirement Advisor. I'm here with Eddie, as always, and today we are digging into something that I think a lot of people just toss in the recycling bin without a second thought: that Annual Notice of Change letter that shows up every fall from your Medicare plan. Eddie, you know the one.

Eddie

Oh, I know the one. It arrives, it looks official, it is thick enough to feel important, and then somehow it tells you almost nothing useful.

Betty

Right! And that is exactly what Ian Schaeffer's piece is about. He's the COO here, and he actually sat down and read one of these letters closely while the team was getting ready for client workshops. What he found, or more precisely what he could not find, is what this episode is about.

Eddie

So here's the headline. He read the letter and just didn't find the deductible. Not the one for medical care and not the one for prescriptions. And his point is not that the plan doesn't have one. It is that the letter just didn't make it easy to find.

Betty

Wait. The one document that is supposed to tell you what changed next year, and it just wasn't there?

Eddie

It left it hard to find. And that matters a lot more than it sounds, because 2027 has more deductibles than 2026 did.

Betty

Okay, that surprised me. More of them. What does that mean?

Eddie

So Ian's team pulled the actual Medicare.gov plan data for Maricopa County, which has 52 standard Advantage plans, meaning not the special needs plans, just the regular ones. Same 52 plans in 2026 and 2027, so you can do a clean comparison.

Betty

And what did they find?

Eddie

In 2026, 11 of those 52 plans had a medical deductible. For 2027, that number is 16. And one more hadn't even posted its number yet when they checked on October 1.

Betty

So five more plans have a medical deductible going into 2027.

Eddie

At minimum. Could be six. And then on the drug side, the maximum a plan can charge for that went from $615 in 2026 to $700 in 2027.

Betty

That's an $85 jump in the cap in one year.

Eddie

And six out of nine stand-alone drug plans in Maricopa set theirs at the full $700.

Betty

That's most of them.

Eddie

When the ceiling goes up, a lot of plans move with it. Worth knowing before you renew.

Betty

No, I caught that. So here is the thing that would really get me. What if my plan kept the exact same name and the same premium? I might just assume nothing changed.

Eddie

Ian makes that point directly. A plan can keep the same name, the same cost, and still add a deductible line that was not there last year. That is why the letter matters, even when everything looks the same on the surface.

Betty

So you can't go by the name and the premium.

Eddie

Not this year.

Betty

Okay so I want to make sure I understand the structure here, because I think people hear the word deductible and they assume there's just one. How many can one plan actually have?

Eddie

More than one. An Advantage plan that includes drug coverage can have a separate threshold for medical care and a completely separate one for prescriptions. And the money you spend on one does not count on the other. They are entirely separate buckets.

Betty

So I could be paying into both at the same time and neither one counts toward the second at all.

Eddie

Correct. Two buckets, two holes to fill before full coverage kicks in.

Betty

And if someone's on Original Medicare with a supplement and a drug plan instead of an Advantage plan?

Eddie

Three places. Part A has its own deductible, Part B has its own, and then the drug plan has one on top of that. So it depends on what kind of coverage you have, but in no scenario is the answer simply one.

Betty

I want to go back to something you said about drug deductibles, because Ian's piece mentions a detail I did not see coming at all.

Eddie

The tier thing.

Betty

Yes. Explain that, because it changes how you think about your drug costs.

Eddie

So the plan handbook spells this out: in some plans that do have a drug deductible, drugs on certain tiers are covered before you hit the deductible. So a low-cost generic might be covered from day one, while a brand-name drug makes you pay the full deductible first.

Betty

Which means two people with the exact same plan could have totally different experiences depending on which drugs they take.

Eddie

Same card in their wallet, completely opposite financial pictures.

Betty

That is one of those things that sounds obvious once someone explains it, but I would have never thought to ask.

Eddie

Most people don't. They see the deductible number, they assume it applies to everything, and they stop there.

Betty

Okay so let's say someone is listening right now and they want to find their real numbers. Where do they go?

Eddie

So Ian lays out three places to look, in order. First, that very document Betty just mentioned, the one a lot of people set aside. Dig it back out, because there should be a summary table near the front with a row for the deductible. If it's there, start there.

Betty

And if it's not easy to find, like Ian's experience suggested?

Eddie

Second stop is Medicare.gov's plan search. You can look up your specific plan and see its 2027 deductibles in the plan details.

Betty

Although, and this is something Ian flagged that I found startling, as of October 4, Medicare.gov still hadn't loaded 2027 doctor information for any of Maricopa's 52 plans.

Eddie

Right. So the plan data is coming in, but it's not all there yet. The enrollment period opens October 15, and some of the information people need is still not loaded. That's the environment people are navigating.

Betty

What's the third source?

Eddie

The plan's own Summary of Benefits document. That one goes further than a summary table because it tells you which services the medical deductible applies to, and that is where it gets really important.

Betty

Because not everything waits for it.

Eddie

Exactly. And Ian makes a point in the article that I want to highlight because I think it's the most practical thing in the whole piece.

Betty

What's that?

Eddie

A new $500 medical deductible that only applies to hospital stays is a very different thing from a $500 deductible that applies to every specialist visit. The dollar amount is the same. The real-world impact is not even close.

Betty

Oh, that's a huge difference. If you see a specialist four or five times a year, that deductible hits you fast.

Eddie

Early in the year, yes. The number alone tells you almost nothing.

Betty

So what should someone write down? Because I think people need a concrete action here, not just go check your documents.

Eddie

Two lines. Your medical deductible, 2026 on the left, 2027 on the right. Your drug deductible, same format. And if either one changed, write next to it which services or prescriptions it applies to.

Betty

Side by side so you can see the change at a glance.

Eddie

And if the three sources, the letter, Medicare.gov, and the Summary of Benefits, give you different numbers, Ian says call the plan directly and ask for both numbers for 2027.

Betty

Which I would not have thought to do if nobody told me the sources sometimes disagree.

Eddie

They can. Data gets updated at different times. The plan is the authoritative source.

Betty

Can I ask you something? We've been talking about finding the number, but the harder part seems like knowing what to do with it once you have it.

Eddie

That's where a Certified Medicare Planner comes in. What Ian describes is that a planner pulls both deductibles for your current plan and for any plans you might be considering, checks which of your specific services and prescriptions each deductible applies to, and puts the 2026 and 2027 numbers side by side before you even sit down to talk.

Betty

So the homework is done for you.

Eddie

More than that. Your situation is in the room. Your prescriptions, your specialists, your usage. A generic deductible comparison doesn't tell you what your year costs. Your specific situation does.

Betty

And Ian mentions that's the work happening in the office right now, ahead of client workshops.

Eddie

This week, yes. They're doing this plan by plan, before anyone sits down at a workshop.

Betty

I want to zoom out for a second because I think there's something bigger here that the article is setting up, and it's not just about deductibles specifically.

Eddie

The series.

Betty

Right, Ian is calling this Part One of What the Letter Leaves Out. He's planning to take one thing a day that the notice doesn't make easy to find, and show people where to get the real answer. Today it's deductibles. Tomorrow he says it's the out-of-pocket maximum.

Eddie

And that preview he gives for it is interesting. The letter lists the cap, but it doesn't show you what a truly bad year costs you all in. He's going to do that arithmetic.

Betty

Those are two different numbers, aren't they. What's listed and what you'd end up spending.

Eddie

They can be. What costs you're exposed to before you hit the max, how services are counted, what's in and out of network. The max is real but it's not the whole picture. That's the next piece.

Betty

See, this is why I think this series matters. People make enrollment decisions based on the premium and maybe the maximum they see on the summary, and those two numbers are almost certainly not the complete story.

Eddie

The premium is what you pay in. The deductible is what you pay before coverage really starts. The maximum is the ceiling on catastrophe. Those are three separate levers, and they all interact.

Betty

And the letter, by Ian's read, makes at least one of those hard to find.

Eddie

That's the whole point of the series.

Betty

Can I just say, as someone who is not the numbers person in this building, this is the kind of thing where I would want someone to just sit with me and show me. Not hand me a stack of documents.

Eddie

That's most people, by the way. It's all technically findable, but pulling it together, comparing it to your actual life, that's the step that doesn't happen on its own.

Betty

And October 15 is not far away.

Eddie

No it is not. And that's not some distant deadline. For anyone who wants to make a change for 2027, the window opens on the 15th.

Betty

How much time do people have, start to finish?

Eddie

The Annual Enrollment Period runs October 15 to December 7, and a change you make starts January 1. The advisors can walk you through what to have ready before you sit down.

Betty

That's shorter than it sounds.

Eddie

The number in the article is 602-281-3898. That's the advisors. That's where to start if you want someone to pull your numbers and sit with you before enrollment opens.

Betty

That image has been stuck in my head this whole conversation, the person who gets the letter, sees the same premium, figures nothing changed, and just drops it straight into the recycling.

Eddie

That's a lot of people.

Betty

And they might be about to have a deductible they weren't budgeting for.

Eddie

One that applies to specialist visits, not just the hospital. Which they'd find out at the appointment, not before.

Betty

That is a stressful way to learn that.

Eddie

Extremely. And it's avoidable. That's what makes this frustrating and also what makes the work Ian's team is doing useful.

Betty

Okay. Let me try to bring this home for someone who is listening in the car or on a walk and wants to know the three things to remember.

Eddie

Deductibles went up. More plans have them in 2027 than in 2026. The drug deductible cap went up by $85 and most stand-alone plans in Maricopa charged the full amount.

Betty

And that number doesn't tell you enough.

Eddie

You need to know which services it applies to. Because a $500 deductible on hospital stays and a $500 deductible on every specialist visit are not the same financial risk at all.

Betty

And if anything in your letter or on Medicare.gov doesn't match, call the plan and ask directly.

Eddie

Call the plan, or call the advisors at 602-281-3898 and let them pull it for you.

Betty

Which, honestly, if I were looking at a stack of documents trying to compare 52 plans, I know which call I'd make.

Eddie

I'd make the second one too, and I'm the numbers person.

Betty

That is maybe the most reassuring thing you've said today.

Eddie

Don't get used to it.

Betty

Everybody, read Ian Schaeffer's piece. It's called What the Letter Leaves Out, Part One, and this is just the beginning of that series. The information is there, the sources are laid out clearly, and the advisors are ready to do this work with you before October 15. You can reach them at 602-281-3898. That conversation costs you nothing. Make it before enrollment opens, not after you get the bill.

Go Deeper

Read next on our site:

Continue the Series

Next episode: What's your worst-case year? What the Letter Leaves Out, part two →
All 5 episodes in What the Letter Leaves Out
Back to all episodes

Ready to talk with an advisor?

The advisors at American Retirement Advisors have been having these conversations for over 25 years. A no-cost discovery session is the fastest way to find out where you actually stand.

Schedule a Discovery Session